Right To Shop:
The Next Big Thing In Health Care
By Josh Archambault and Nic Horton
August 5, 2016
Why should the exact same treatment for pneumonia cost $5,000 in one building and $124,000 in another?
Or the exact same infusion drug for a chronically ill patient that requires them every six weeks cost
$14,000 per shot in one setting, but $28,000 down the street? Why should patients have to pay so much
more, simply based on where they park their cars? The answer is simple: they shouldn’t.
But the black box of pricing leaves patients in the dark. As a result, the financial futures of too many American
families are in jeopardy as their paychecks fail to keep up with skyrocketing health care costs.
The real shame is that Americans would shop for better prices if they could – comparison shopping is part
of the American way of life. In fact, according to a poll the Foundation for Government Accountability
commissioned last year, 88% of voters say they regularly comparison shop for the best deal. Consumers
shop for transportation, choosing between public transportation, conventional taxi services or new, innovative
ridesharing through companies like Uber and Lyft. If they’re looking for entertainment, Redbox,
Netflix, Amazon Prime, and numerous other companies provide a multitude of choices at competitive
But patients struggle to shop for health care, contributing to out-of-control costs across the board.
Unpacking the Health Care Crisis
In today’s world, deductibles, co-pays, and premiums are rising. This means health care costs are consuming
more and more of the average family’s budget. In fact, some experts project that, within 10 years, 30
percent of a family’s budget will be consumed by health care costs. Within 20 years, it’s expected to reach
almost 50 percent.
And simply having insurance will not solve the problem because insurance is no longer a protection from
medical debt. In fact, according to one national survey, 7 out of 10 people with medical debt have
The number of consumers facing increased cost sharing has also spiked. Small business employees who
faced $1,000 single-deductibles was just 16 percent in 2006. By 2014, the percentage spiked to 61 percent.
Amidst these changes, costs continue to grow, physician satisfaction is declining, and population health
continues to decline.
This status quo hurts the most vulnerable, like the single mother struggling to pay for care for her kids or
Americans with chronic health problems. And with no end in sight, health care costs are quickly becoming a
national crisis that cannot be ignored.
In today’s post-ACA world, how can policymakers reverse the tide?
Transparency Is Just One Piece Of Cost Puzzle
Price transparency initiatives have been all the rage over the last decade and for good reason. Transparency
is a key component of any free market and it’s visibly lacking in the health care system. And without it,
providers within the same zip code, or even right across the street from each other, can charge significantly
different prices for the exact some procedures – and they do.
A few examples of astronomical price variation taken from recent headlines include:
- Pneumonia treatment (without complications) ranging from $5,093 to $124,051;
- A knee MRI in New York City ranging from $440 to $4,500;
- Specialty drug infusions ranging from $3,500 to $22,000, within miles;
- An infusible drug ranges from $14,000 to $28,000 at two Maine hospitals in the same town.
States have tried to tackle this problem with robust transparency laws. But unfortunately, patients have
struggled to engage. In fact, in Massachusetts – which arguably has the most sweeping transparency law in
the country – since most providers have failed to even comply with the most basic requirements of the law,
patients are unable to efficiently shop.
According to a survey by the Catalyst for Payment Reform, 98 percent of health plans around the country
claim to have a cost calculator tools, but only 2 percent of patient members use them.
Case Study: Right to Shop-Type Model In Practice
Just a few years ago, the state of New Hampshire commissioned Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield to
setup a Right To Shop-style system that gave state employees shopping tools and incentives. Powered by
Vital’s SmartShopper, the outcomes of the program have been nothing short of impressive.
With three years of education and outreach under their belt, the program has produced $12 million in
savings with over $1 million paid out to patients as rewards .
Here are some of the top takeaways from a Right to Shop experience:
- Incentives drive shopping. Members are 11 times more likely to use a transparency program
when incentive rewards are included.
- Incentives sustain shopping. Roughly 90% of program enrollees have shopped at least
once, with two-thirds repeat shopping and earning incentives each year from 2011 – 2014. By
contrast, most insurer transparency tools report 2% engagement.
- Incentives drive savings. The program averages approximately $650 in savings each time it
- Incentives produce a return on investment. In 2015, New Hampshire’s program achieved
a 13:1 ROI (return on investment).
These results for state employees are even more remarkable given that this highly unionized workforce
continues to have a very generous insurance, giving them little incentive to shop. If these employees faced
sizable deductibles, their engagement would likely be even higher.
It’s Not Just New Hampshire – Right To Shop Is Spreading
New Hampshire has blazed the trail, but thanks to their success, Right To Shop is now spreading across the
map. Incentive-driven programs are springing up in Kansas, Kentucky, and Massachusetts. In addition,
Right To Shop legislation has been filed in Florida, Maine, and South Carolina, with more to join them next
Private sector transparency vendors are also getting into the game. In addition to Vitals, companies such as
Healthcare Bluebook already offer similar incentive-based programs. Other transparency vendors such
Castlight, HealthSparq, myEasyBook by UnitedHealthcare, and PokitDok can and should add incentives to
take their transparency programs to the next level.
This momentum should come as no surprise. Right To Shop is a commonsense approach to addressing
exploding health care costs. It’s simple, flexible, and, best of all, it works. By extending these concepts to all
insured consumers, Right To Shop will bring much-needed relief to patients.
NOTE: To learn more about Right to Shop, visit: thefga.org/righttoshop
1. “Curing the Health Care Headache”, The Foundation for Government Accountability, (September 28, 2015), https://thefga.
2. Michael Karpman and Sharon K. Long, “Most Adults with Medical Debt Had Health Insurance at the Time the Debt Was Incurred”,
Health Reform Monitoring Survey, (May 21, 2015), http://hrms.urban.org/briefs/Most-Adults-with-Medical-
3. “2014 Employer Health Benefits Survey”, The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, (September 10, 2014), http://kff.org/report-section/
4. Aisling Maki, “Survey: 34 Pct. Of Physicians to Leave Medical Practice”, Memphis Daily News, (August 8, 2012), https://www.memphisdailynews.
5. “Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion”, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, (February 23, 2016), http://www.
6. “Transparency and Disclosure of Health Costs and Provider Payments: State Actions”, National Conference of State Legislatures,
(August 2015), http://www.ncsl.org/research/health/transparency-and-disclosure-health-costs.aspx
7. “Mass. Healthcare Price Transparency Law Still Not a Reality”, Pioneer Institute, (August 12, 2015), http://pioneerinstitute.
8. Melanie Evans, “Prices hard to come by for Massachusetts patients despite transparency law”, Modern Healthcare, (June 24, 2015),
9. “The National Scorecard and Compendium on Payment Reform”, Catalyst for Payment Reform, http://www.catalyzepaymentreform.org/how-we-catalyze/national-scorecard
Searching for someone else you can pay money for papers made effectively and well-timed? Makes use of the greatest essay creating business and get your advanced schooling living to the greatest